Why Now Is the Perfect Time for Talented Copywriters
By Kai Sewald, Lead Creative Innovation at Waechter PR
For quite a while now, more and more companies have been asking themselves: Do we really need to outsource content creation, or can we do it ourselves? The trend towards ‘in-house’ production can be felt everywhere – not least because of the use of all manner of AI tools, agencies are being hastily denied the added value of their external creative input. Because let’s be honest: With good, in-depth prompts, mainstream AI systems do indeed produce solid results.
For our independent network agencies at Worldwide Partners Inc., this in turn raises several questions: How do we (re)position ourselves in the age of AI? What kind of advisory services can we sensibly provide in the future? How do we need to adapt our portfolio to new contexts and requirements? And are copywriters still in demand these days? Strategies are consequently being optimised, business models adapted and even new career paths created.
However, it is also true that, without the necessary fine-tuning, you are unlikely to achieve much with ‘content generation at the touch of a button’, as the target audience’s expectations regarding highly personalised liquid content are rising rapidly in line with the volume of content published at short notice.
Social media, in particular, is being flooded with an ever-increasing number of generalisations, platitudes and posts by so-called experts who merely scratch the surface rather than providing a deep dive – and are consequently ‘swiped away’ in true Tinder style, as they fail to act as ‘scroll-stoppers’. Frustrated users are even talking about quitting social media and planning to delete their accounts entirely. Detective work is also very much en vogue; the comments section is teeming with investigators who expose the alleged use of AI and, consequently, inauthentic content. Particularly under fire here is the dash (which, paradoxically, has become quite dear to the all-too-human author of this article as a stylistic device over the years).
So, what can we do to start providing authentic content for our readers again?
THE RENAISSANCE OF WRITING, OR
How can you stand out from the machine-generated, run-of-the-mill drivel?
Many years ago, whilst studying linguistics and literature at LMU Munich, I wrote a treatise on ‘Flaws as embellishments in early modern poetry’. The idea behind it: In order to set themselves apart from the clichéd ideals of beauty of the time, a wide variety of Renaissance poets praised women who were different: dark-skinned rather than fair-skinned, brunette rather than blonde, curvier than usual – early examples of diversity, so to speak.
In a similar vein, I recently came across a LinkedIn post in which the author called for more humanity on social media. After all, social media is, by definition, intended for interaction between human beings! However, it does seem rather bizarre to use grammar and comma errors in a post to demonstrate the authenticity of ‘imperfect content’ to the community. What would be the logical consequence: “Wanted: Copywriter (m/f/d) with poor spelling skills”? Or should the AI assistant be prompted to make mistakes on purpose so that the content feels more ‘real’?
Creativity also requires reflection: Everyday interruptions – such as the beep of the dishwasher whilst working from home, which briefly snaps me out of my thoughts, or the evening shower, which prompts me to rethink what I’ve written earlier – are missing when AI generates pages of text in just a few moments. Not to mention the greater passion for and deeper engagement with a text that one spends hours – sometimes days – working on. The current enthusiasm for “Wild Wood”, a film created over 15 years of painstaking, detail-oriented craftsmanship by absolute nerds, speaks volumes about why human audiences are already growing weary of ‘AI slop’.
In essence, an editor at Bayerischer Rundfunk recently told me on the phone: “Now, more than ever, is the time for talented copywriters whose work is characterised by a distinctive style and thus stands out from AI-generated text in a way that is evident to the reader.”
Be Brave: Strong Statements
Despite the convenience and time-saving benefits that AI brings in many respects, we should therefore ask ourselves: Do I personally recognise myself in my text? Does it reflect my critical views? Is it evident – both in tone and on page – that I wrote it myself and no one else? Was I bold enough to make strong statements, paint unusual pictures and draw new comparisons? And am I sufficiently well-informed to stand by them with confidence? Even with the fast pace of (work) life, have I taken enough time to review what I’ve said, to question it where necessary, and to refine it to my own standards? And perhaps most importantly: Does my text offer real added value to the readership? Incidentally, these quality criteria apply just as much to the human author as they do to the brand as the messenger or the painstakingly crafted corporate voice.
Ever since the hype surrounding the launch of ChatGPT – which seems like a lifetime ago – AI-generated or AI-assisted writing has been an integral part of a copywriter’s job (even if many are still coming to terms with their changed role after all these years).
But right now is the time to step back and reflect on what has always made for a good piece of writing: a personal, recognisable writing style; well-founded, thoroughly researched, valuable content; and, perhaps most importantly, a perceptible passion for the text and its central message.
As a content creator with many years’ experience, I am convinced that readers notice this attention to detail – and it sets you apart from mass-produced, machine-generated content in a positive way.
What are your experiences? How do you approach AI-assisted content creation?
PS: This post was written entirely without the help of AI, on a rainy Monday afternoon in November that simply called for a spot of typing for old times’ sake. Refreshingly straightforward, extremely sustainable and (once again) great fun. Unfortunately, I haven’t yet asked Claude, Gemini and Co-Pilot how they’ve been passing the time in the meanwhile. Perhaps I can find out soon during a virtual game of poker with the digital assistants…
Title Image created with love and AI